We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Best Pillow Top Mattress
Best Pillow Top Mattress

Best Pillow Top Mattress

Alternative Text
Review by Claire
OUR EXPERT ANALYST UPDATED 14.10.2020
Read More
We’ll bet that the dream bed you picture in your imagination has a pillow top. This layer of cushioning can’t help but seem plush and luxurious – and many brands have incorporated this crowd-pleaser into their designs for just that reason. The benefits extend beyond aesthetics, with advantages around motion isolation and pressure relief. If you want a pillow top mattress in your life, this is a great place to start. Our best-rated pillowtop mattress and buyers’ guide will help with your search.

The best pillow top mattresses

  

Quick overview of the top 7 pillow top mattresses

Editor’s Pick

REASONS TO BUY
  • You get free white-glove delivery and old mattress removal
  • It has glowing customer reviews
  • It is available in three firmness options and two height profiles
  • It has an organic, anti-microbial cotton cover
  • 120-night sleep trial, 15-year warranty

View Deal

$200 Off

Best for Support

REASONS TO BUY
  • It has a Tencal cooling cover
  • Support is zoned for targeted effectiveness
  • It’s one of the best firm pillow top mattresses
  • It’s a great value bed
  • 100-night sleep trial, 15-year warranty

Best Hybrid

REASONS TO BUY
  • It has a thick memory foam Euro top for pressure relief
  • It is suitable for all body types
  • It’s affordable considering its construction
  • It has an accommodating foam feel
  • 365-night sleep trial, lifetime warranty

View Deal

Get $200 Off

Best for Heavy People

REASONS TO BUY
  • It is specially designed for people with big frames
  • It is luxury quality at an affordable price
  • Zoned latex support layer
  • It is proven to be durable
  • It has cooling properties
  • 120-night sleep trial, lifetime warranty

View Deal

$200 Off – Code: SLEEP200

Best Eco-Friendly

REASONS TO BUY
  • It’s not exorbitantly priced for an organic mattress
  • It has zoned support
  • It is a match for all body types
  • It has natural health and anti-microbial benefits
  • One-year sleep trial, 25-year warranty

Best Value

REASONS TO BUY
  • It’s supportive and durable enough for all body shapes
  • It comes in three firmness options for all sleep types
  • It’s a great bed for couples
  • Its quality is remarkable for its price
  • 100-night trial, lifetime warranty, lifetime comfort guarantee

View Deal

20% Off

Best for Side Sleepers

REASONS TO BUY
  • It’s got organic and eco-friendly components
  • It’s ultra-soft and luxurious
  • It’s got two layers of coils for support
  • Its quality is remarkable for its price
  • 365-night trial, 25-year warranty

View Deal

Save $175 – Coupon: NATURE175

The best pillow top mattresses reviewed

1. Editor’s Pick – Saatva

Who is the Saatva good for:
  • All shapes and sizes
  • All sleep positions
  • Anyone who wants delivery and old mattress removal taken care of
  • Luxury shoppers who want a bargain
  • Shoppers who want to see positive reviews
The Saatva Classic makes you feel like you’re getting a luxury bed at a bargain. This hybrid model comes in three firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. This means, across all sleeping preferences, there is a bed to meet your needs. There are also two height profiles to choose from. No matter the combination you choose, every Saatva Classic has a big, comfy pillow top. Its dual coil construction makes it supremely supportive, with responsiveness and pressure relief from the pillow top layer. Its large following of happy customers have reported pain relief and comfort from this fantastic all-rounder mattress. Available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King, and Split Cal King.
PROS
  • It’s affordable luxury
  • You get the choice of different firmness and height options
  • Free mattress setup and old mattress removal
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • Dual coil construction for support, yet pressure relieving at the same time
CONS
  • Returns are not free
  • There have been some reports of sagging

CLAIM OFFER HERE

Read Full Review

2. Best Pillow Top Mattress for Support – Helix Sleep

Who is the Helix Sleep good for:
  • All shapes and sizes
  • Back and stomach sleepers who need support
  • Sleepers who suffer with back pain
  • Fans of mattresses with a responsive feel
  • Value shoppers
Back and stomach sleepers need a firmer mattress to keep their bodies in correct alignment while they sleep. Incorrect spinal alignment and sinking hips and trunks can lead to pain, discomfort, and poor sleep quality – which can negatively affect health. The Helix Midnight Luxe is firm enough to offer the right amount of support and was designed with the human body in mind. Zoned lumbar support means you get support where your body needs it. Its pillow top is plush and comfortable, with a cool Tencal cover with Gel Visco Foam for anyone worried about sleeping hot. Available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King.
PROS
  • It’s both pressure-relieving and supportive
  • Helix’s handy quiz helps you with your final mattress choice
  • Zoned support for pain relief and support
  • Breathable, cool cover
  • Impressive durability
CONS
  • While it should work for most side sleepers, some will prefer a softer mattress
  • It is a bit on the expensive side if you’re shopping on a strict budget

CLAIM OFFER HERE

Read Full Review

3. Best Hybrid Pillow Top Mattress – DreamCloud

Who is the DreamCloud good for:
  • All shapes and sizes
  • All sleeping positions
  • Value shoppers
  • Couples
  • Anyone who likes a little bit of luxury
Who doesn’t love a luxury touch here and there? The new DreamCloud Premier has a few – and it’s pillowtop is an easy place to start. This Euro top has added foam, making it a thick, pressure relieving surface with an accommodating feel. It also has cashmere woven into it for unquestionable softness. While it has enough foam for you to get the benefits of this material, it is more responsive and durable – a perfect choice for people of all shapes and sizes. Its construction of foam and individually pocketed coils makes it firm enough to be supportive, which means back and stomach sleepers won’t have any problems with this bed. For its level of quality and durability, it’s also remarkably affordable. Available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King.
PROS
  • It balances pressure relief and support
  • It offers very good edge support
  • It is accommodating to different preferences and sleep styles
  • It offers superlative value for money
  • Its construction makes for impressive durability
CONS
  • Petite side sleepers or anyone who likes a soft bed might find it a bit firm
  • It’s not cheap if you’re shopping on a strict budget

CLAIM OFFER HERE

Read Full Review

4. Best Pillow Top Mattress for Heavy People – Winkbeds

Who is the Winkbeds good for:
  • All body types, but specifically people with bigger figures
  • Value shoppers
  • Anyone who likes a responsive feel to a mattress
  • Anyone who would benefit from targeted support
  • Anyone worried about sleeping hot
If you are heavier in stature, you shouldn’t have to order a bed made for lighter folk and hope it works. With the WinkBed Plus, you don’t have to. This bed has been made with bigger figures in mind. That means it is supportive enough to keep you sleeping comfortably – and durable enough to outlast many other models. WinkBeds also hasn’t compromised on quality in this bed – it is a luxury offering. Its Euro top is ultra-comfortable, with a Tencal cover and gel-infused foam for cooling. It also has a zoned latex support layer for responsiveness and firmness according to the shape of your body. Available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King.
PROS
  • The company policies from WinkBeds are extremely generous
  • It comes with a lifetime 50% off comfort replacement option
  • It is affordable for its level of craftsmanship
  • Its got an accommodating feel
CONS
  • It weighs in quite heavy if you are planning on moving
  • It’s priced a little high for anyone shopping on a strict budget

CLAIM OFFER HERE

Read Full Review

5. Best Eco-Friendly Pillow Top Mattress – Avocado

Who is the Avocado good for:
  • Eco-shoppers and vegans
  • All sleeping positions
  • All body types
  • Anyone who suffers with skin complaints and allergies
  • Sleepers who like responsiveness
Eco-friendly products are fast growing in popularity – and mattresses are no different. Avocado is a latex mattress, which means it is naturally responsive, breathable, and hypoallergenic. If you’re worried about chemicals and synthetic materials, Avocado is going to be one of your top choices. It comes with its pillow top as an optional extra – and it’s worth it. It adds two inches of latex and, with it, that extra touch of luxury and invaluable pressure relief – perfect for side sleepers. You can also choose between organic certified wool or their vegan options depending on your ethics. Available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King.
PROS
  • Made from certified organic materials, which are kind to you and the planet
  • Avocado offers generous company policies
  • A good choice for light sleepers worried about motion isolation
  • Zoned support structure for pain relief and long-term comfort
CONS
  • Natural materials are priced a little higher than their foam counterparts

CLAIM OFFER HERE

Read Full Review

6. Best Value Pillow Top Mattress – Nest Bedding

Who is the Nest Bedding good for: 
  • All shapes and sizes
  • All sleeping positions
  • Couples
  • Value shoppers
  • Anyone buying a mattress with the long run in mind
We’ve reviewed some online mattress brands which offer amazing value, but the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid is an undeniable frontrunner as one of the best rated pillow top mattresses for quality and affordability. Quite simply, you get a great bed for your dollars. Worried it’s not going to fit your needs? The Alexander Signature Hybrid comes in three firmness levels and has an accommodating feel for all sleep preferences and body types. Choose between the Plush, Medium, and Luxury Firm options depending on your primary sleep position. No matter which one you choose, it has the support of springs and incredible pressure-relieving responsiveness in its gel-infused pillow top. Available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King, Split Cal King.
PROS
  • Generous company policies
  • Three firmness levels to choose from
  • Internal split option to accommodate sleepers with different preferences
  • Easy to change sleep and sex position
  • Plush option is a really soft pillow top mattress – perfect for side sleepers
CONS
  • While it’s affordable, it’s not a cheap bed for budget shoppers
  • There is no true firm option for heavy people in high weight brackets or anyone with needs around support

CLAIM OFFER HERE

Read Full Review

7. Best Pillow Top Mattress for Side Sleepers – Brentwood

Who is the Brentwood good for:
  • Side sleepers (and all sleepers)
  • All body shapes
  • Value shoppers
  • Anyone who wants zoned support
  • Eco-shoppers
If you’re a side sleeper, you need a soft, pressure-relieving mattress to keep your shoulders and hips pain-free. The Brentwood Home Oceano is about a medium-soft on the firmness scale – and it has a plush pillow top – making it the best pillow top mattress for side sleepers. It is also set apart from other beds in its class because of its focus on eco-friendly materials. It’s GREENGUARD Gold certified and its pillow top boasts organic New Zealand wool which is naturally moisture wicking. It also has a plant-based Tencal cover which, together with the open-cell foam and dual coil system keeps airflow to a maximum (great for cooling). Available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, and Split King.
PROS
  • You get plenty of time to decide if you like it
  • It’s got an extremely accommodating feel
  • It’s extremely pressure-relieving for side sleepers
  • It’s responsive, which means you can switch between sleep and sex positions easily
  • It’s temperature neutral
CONS
  • It’s not going to work if you (or the person you share your bed with) are looking for a firm mattress (split option available for the King)
  • There is no true firm option for heavy people in high weight brackets or anyone with needs around support

CLAIM OFFER HERE

Read Full Review

Mattress buying guide for pillow top mattresses

Not all pillow tops are made the same. As you will see from our range of favorites above, they are separated by many different features. From firmness and support for back and stomach sleepers to softness and pressure relief for side sleepers, there’s plenty to think about before you take the plunge and buy a new mattress. Pillow tops often have the result of offering extra pressure relief and motion isolation properties – with positive implications for comfort and sleep quality. Let’s drill down into the fundamentals of pillow top mattresses.

What is a pillow top mattress?

While the support and comfort layers may differ, pillow top mattresses have a soft, cushioned topper built into the mattress. This topper can incorporate different materials to give it its feel. This can range from memory foam, latex, and cotton to wool. Whatever a pillow top is made from, most tend to make for elevated softness and comfort. A pillow top is usually in the region of two to four inches thick.

What is the difference between a pillow top and a euro top?

Euro top mattresses are usually even softer than pillow top mattresses, but they also have a reputation for support, making them an exciting option for anyone who suffers from pain in the back or neck. They also tend to be denser in construction when compared to pillow top mattresses. A Euro top is often more durable than a pillow top (keeping its shape a little longer) and has slightly better edge support. They also tend to come with a higher price tag. A Euro top is also ‘built in’ to the design, whereas a pillow top can be thought of as a separate, stitched-on component. Don’t confuse either with a topper, which is a removable optional addition.

Who should get a pillowtop mattress?

Anyone on the hunt for a luxury feel

The cushiony, cozy comfort of a pillow top gives any mattress a luxury touch, which is perfect if you enjoy the natural indulgence of a good night’s sleep.

If you’re looking for softness and support

Pillow top mattresses have the effect of softening the feel of firmer mattresses. If you like the feeling of being cushioned by a bed, a pillow top is a great way to achieve this – even if your sleep preferences call for firmer mattresses.

Anyone who like a bed with a high profile

Taller beds have a connotation of luxury and pillow top mattresses up the inches that little bit.

What are the advantages of pillow top mattresses?

Comfort

We can’t cover it enough – the primary perk of pillow top mattresses is the way it feels. You should look forward to going to bed every night and pillow top mattresses up the ante on comfort. Even on firm beds, you get the benefit of a plush feel.

Pain relief

Pillow top mattresses tend to provide additional pressure relief, which can have real benefits for anyone who suffers with pain. This comes down to a combination of contouring, support, and alignment. While back support may vary from mattress to mattress, side sleepers usually have a long list of compliments for the pressure relieving properties of pillowtop mattresses.

Motion isolation

Pillow tops are prevalent on hybrid bed designs. This combination of individual pocketed coils with this comfort topper is usually highly effective at isolating motion. If you are a light sleeper – or if your partner is particularly restless at night – this feature will be a real crowd pleaser.

You’re spoilt for choice

Pillow top mattresses come in many different varieties. This means there is a mattress to suit your sleep type, body shape, ethics, and preference. Pillow tops come as an optional extra on some popular mattress brands but, whether you are a side sleeper, eco-shopper, health nut, or simple luxury seeker, there is something out there for you.

What are the disadvantages of pillow top mattresses?

They don’t always age well

Some pillow top materials degrade and sag a little quicker than other materials used throughout the bed.

You may need to buy special sheets

The extra mattress thickness means you may need to invest in some deep sheets for pillow top mattresses.

Some sleep hot

The density of materials and the additional layer above comfort layers can cause heat retention in some pillow top mattress models.

It’s not the best option for heavy sleepers

While many mattresses will work for heavy sleepers, the sometimes compromised durability can be problematic for people in heavy weight brackets. Check out our review on the best pillowtop mattress for heavy people above.

Conclusion

Across all the mattresses outlined above, you are getting the crème de la crème of pillow top mattresses. There’s something for every kind of sleeper in our top-rated pillow top mattress list. On lying down, you are immediately struck by how comfortable they are – and they add a touch of elegance to your night’s sleep too.

FAQ

Yes. Pillow top mattresses come in different varieties and some are better than others.

Some pillow top mattresses will offer better support than others, but many models do offer heightened support.

The quality will vary from mattress to mattress, but investing in a high-quality pillow top mattress is usually a mark of elegance and comfort for bedroom shopping.

Pillow top mattresses provide enhanced pressure relief, cushioned comfort, and excellent motion isolation.

A high-quality pillow top mattress can last in the region of eight to ten years.

This depends on the materials used. Fiberfill and low-quality foams develop compressions and sag faster than high-quality materials.

Subscribe today!

Get the latest deals, discounts, reviews and giveaways